In 'Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction', Paul Meehl challenges the effectiveness of clinical judgment in psychological assessment compared to statistical methods. He presents compelling evidence that statistical models consistently outperform clinicians in predicting outcomes. Throughout the book, Meehl examines the biases and limitations of human intuition, urging a reevaluation of conventional practices in psychology. His provocative insights spark a crucial debate on the role of science versus experience in understanding human behavior. Discover how this groundbreaking work reshapes the way we think about prediction, judgment, and the future of clinical psychology.
By Paul Meehl
Published: NaN
"In the realm of human prediction, the mind's narrative often overshadows the cold logic of statistics, revealing the paradox that our most instinctive judgments can lead us astray."
Clinical versus Statistical Prediction is Paul Meehl's famous examination of benefits and disutilities related to the different ways of combining information to make predictions. It is a clarifying analysis as relevant today as when it first appeared. A major methodological problem for clinical psychology concerns the relation between clinical and actuarial methods of arriving at diagnoses and predicting behavior. Without prejudging the question as to whether these methods are fundamentally different, we can at least set forth the obvious distinctions between them in practical applications. The problem is to predict how a person is going to behave: What is the most accurate way to go about this task? Clinical versus Statistical Prediction offers a penetrating and thorough look at the pros and cons of human judgment versus actuarial integration of information as applied to the prediction problem. Widely considered the leading text on the subject, Paul Meehl's landmark analysis is reprinted here in its entirety, including his updated preface written forty-two years after the first publication of the book. This classic work is a must-have for students and practitioners interested in better understanding human behavior, for anyone wanting to make the most accurate decisions from all sorts of data, and for those interested in the ethics and intricacies of prediction. As Meehl puts it, "When one is dealing with human lives and life opportunities, it is immoral to adopt a mode of decision-making which has been demonstrated repeatedly to be either inferior in success rate or, when equal, costlier to the client or the taxpayer."
Showing 8 of 27 similar books
Joe Rogan is a multifaceted American entertainer known primarily for his work as a comedian, podcast host, and commentator. He gained widespread recognition through his immensely popular podcast, "The Joe Rogan Experience," which has featured in-depth conversations with a diverse array of guests, including scientists, celebrities, and politicians. Though not primarily known for literature, Rogan has contributed to the field with his thought-provoking discussions that often explore philosophical and intellectual ideas. Additionally, he has authored the book "Mastering the Rubber Guard," which delves into Brazilian Jiu-Jitsu techniques, showcasing his expertise in martial arts. Rogan's influence extends beyond traditional media, impacting contemporary discourse through his unique blend of humor, curiosity, and critical thinking.
Jon Stewart is an American comedian, writer, and former host of The Daily Show, where he gained fame for his satirical take on news and politics. Stewart transformed The Daily Show into a critical voice in American media, blending humor with hard-hitting commentary on political and social issues. After stepping down from the show, Stewart has continued to advocate for causes like 9/11 first responders and veterans' rights. He is also a filmmaker, directing the political satire film Irresistible. Stewart remains a significant figure in American culture, known for his wit, activism, and influence on political discourse.
Stanislav Grof is a pioneering psychiatrist and researcher in the field of transpersonal psychology. Born in 1931, he is renowned for his extensive work on the therapeutic potential of non-ordinary states of consciousness, particularly through the use of LSD and holotropic breathwork. Grof's seminal book, "The Holotropic Mind," co-authored with Hal Zina Bennett, has had a profound impact on the understanding of human consciousness and spiritual experiences. He has authored over 20 books and numerous scientific papers, significantly contributing to the literature on psychology and psychotherapy. Grof is also one of the founders of the International Transpersonal Association, promoting the integration of spiritual dimensions with psychological practice.
Brendon Burchard is a high-performance coach, motivational speaker, and bestselling author, best known for his books High Performance Habits and The Motivation Manifesto. He helps individuals and organizations achieve peak performance through strategies focused on clarity, energy, and productivity. Brendon’s work emphasizes the importance of personal growth and developing habits that lead to sustained success. He has coached Fortune 500 CEOs, Olympians, and other high-achieving individuals. Brendon is also the founder of the High Performance Academy, where he trains people to lead more impactful and successful lives.
Daniel Kahneman is a renowned psychologist and Nobel laureate, celebrated for his groundbreaking work in the field of behavioral economics. He co-authored the seminal book "Thinking, Fast and Slow," which explores the dual systems of thought and has profoundly influenced both psychology and economics. Kahneman's research, particularly his collaboration with Amos Tversky on prospect theory, challenged the traditional rational model of decision-making and earned him the Nobel Prize in Economic Sciences in 2002. His contributions have reshaped our understanding of human judgment, decision-making, and the nature of happiness. Kahneman continues to be a leading voice in the study of cognitive biases and heuristics.
Jordan Peterson is a Canadian psychologist, author, and professor, best known for his work on psychology, political philosophy, and cultural criticism. His book 12 Rules for Life: An Antidote to Chaos became a global bestseller, offering advice on personal responsibility, order, and meaning in life. Peterson’s lectures, which cover topics like mythology, religion, and self-improvement, have garnered millions of views online, making him a polarizing figure in both academic and popular circles. He is known for his critiques of political correctness and his emphasis on individual responsibility. Peterson’s influence has sparked widespread debate about free speech, identity politics, and mental health.
Keith Rabois is a prominent American entrepreneur, investor, and author known for his significant contributions to the tech industry and startup ecosystem. He played crucial roles in the early success of companies like PayPal, LinkedIn, Square, and Yelp, earning a reputation as a skilled operator and strategic thinker. As a partner at Founders Fund and later at Khosla Ventures, Rabois has invested in and advised numerous successful startups. In addition to his business ventures, he has written insightful articles and essays on technology, entrepreneurship, and innovation, contributing to the broader discourse on these subjects. Rabois continues to influence the tech world with his strategic insights and thought leadership.
Adam Grant is a renowned organizational psychologist and bestselling author, celebrated for his influential work on motivation and workplace dynamics. He is a professor at the Wharton School of the University of Pennsylvania, where he has been the youngest tenured professor and earned numerous teaching awards. Grant's books, including "Give and Take," "Originals," and "Think Again," have been translated into multiple languages and have topped bestseller lists worldwide. His research and insights are frequently featured in major media outlets, and he hosts the popular podcast "WorkLife." Through his writing and speaking, Grant has profoundly impacted the fields of psychology, business, and education.
“In the realm of human prediction, the mind's narrative often overshadows the cold logic of statistics, revealing the paradox that our most instinctive judgments can lead us astray.”
Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction
By Paul Meehl
Discover a world of knowledge through our extensive collection of book summaries.
Paul Meehl (1909-2003) was a distinguished American psychologist and philosopher known for his substantial contributions to the fields of clinical psychology and psychometrics. His notable works include 'Clinical Versus Statistical Prediction: A Theoretical Analysis and a Review of the Evidence' and 'Psychodiagnosis: Selected Papers.' Meehl's writing is characterized by rigorous logical analysis and a commitment to empirical research, often challenging conventional wisdom in psychology. His emphasis on the interplay of theory and practice has had a lasting impact on both clinical settings and psychological research.
Key information about the book.
Buy on Amazon
Buy via BookShopSupport local bookstores: BookShop gives a portion of each sale to independent bookshops!
In "Nudge," behavioral economists Richard Thaler and Cass Sunstein unveil the subtle art of influencing choices and shaping outcomes without restricting freedom. They explore how small, seemingly insignificant changes in the way options are presented can lead to drastically improved decisions in health, finance, and overall happiness. With compelling real-world examples and engaging insights, the authors demonstrate how understanding human psychology can empower individuals and policymakers alike. Dive into a world where choice architecture transforms lives and reshapes society's approach to welfare. Discover the hidden nudges that could change everything about the way we choose!
In "The Black Swan," Nassim Nicholas Taleb explores the profound impact of rare and unpredictable events—those seemingly impossible occurrences that shape our world in transformative ways. He challenges conventional thinking, revealing how humans consistently underestimate uncertainty and overvalue what we can predict. Through compelling anecdotes and thought-provoking insights, Taleb illustrates how we can prepare for the unexpected rather than just cling to past experiences. The book urges readers to embrace randomness and rethink the frameworks we use to navigate life’s complexities. Will you recognize your own blind spots before the next Black Swan strikes?
In 'The Curve,' Nicholas Lovell delves into the transformative power of the digital age on traditional business models. He presents a compelling argument about how value creation and customer engagement are evolving in the internet era. With insightful case studies, Lovell challenges businesses to rethink their strategies and embrace the new economic landscape. The book ultimately reveals how organizations can thrive by leveraging an interconnected world and embracing change. Readers will be left curious about how to adapt their own practices in this rapidly shifting market.
In 'The Moorland Cottage', Elizabeth Cleghorn Gaskell crafts a poignant tale of innocence lost and the trials of love against the backdrop of rural England. Two sisters, Mary and her headstrong sibling, navigate the complexities of social class and romantic entanglements, leading them to unexpected consequences. As they confront the harsh realities of their lives, their choices reveal the intricacies of human emotions and the impact of societal expectations. Gaskell's rich character development and vivid settings draw readers into a world where every decision carries weight. This captivating novel invites you to ponder the nature of happiness and the sacrifices one makes for love.
In 'The Social Animal', Joshua and Elliot Aronson explore the psychological and social forces shaping human behavior through rich anecdotes and groundbreaking research. The authors take readers on a journey through the intricacies of love, hate, and the powerful influence of social contexts on individual decisions. Juxtaposing captivating storytelling with scientific insights, they unravel the complexities of conformity, prejudice, and self-identity. This thought-provoking exploration challenges our understanding of what it means to be human in a social world. Prepare to question your beliefs and see the connections between psychology and everyday life like never before.
'Super Pumped' by Mike Isaac delves into the meteoric rise and turbulent fall of Uber, exploring the audacious vision of its founder, Travis Kalanick. As the company shakes up the transportation industry, ethical dilemmas and personal struggles emerge, painting a vivid portrait of ambition and chaos. Readers will be captivated by the fierce battles within the company and the relentless drive for success. Intriguingly, this narrative reveals the dark side of tech innovation and startup culture, leaving you questioning the cost of disruption. Prepare to be enthralled by a story of power, greed, and the quest for dominance in a rapidly changing world.
In 'Mistakes Were Made (but Not by Me)', Carol Tavris and Elliot Aronson explore the psychological mechanisms of self-justification and the often-unconscious ways we avoid admitting our wrongs. With compelling examples from history, psychology, and personal anecdotes, the authors reveal why people, from individuals to large organizations, refuse to accept accountability. This thought-provoking book challenges readers to confront their own biases and the cognitive dissonance that influences decision-making. Will you choose to embrace the discomfort of acknowledging your mistakes? Dive into this enlightening read and discover the profound impact of accountability on personal growth and relationships.
In the brutal landscapes of the American West, a nameless teenage protagonist, known only as 'the Kid,' embarks on a harrowing journey filled with violence and existential reflection. He joins a merciless group of Indian-hunters led by the enigmatic figure known as Judge Holden, whose philosophical musings blur the lines between civilization and savagery. As they traverse through a world steeped in bloodshed and moral ambiguity, the Kid confronts the darkest aspects of humanity and his own soul. McCarthy's unflinching prose paints a chilling tableau of the American frontier, exploring themes of fate, power, and the human condition. 'Blood Meridian' is not just a tale of survival, but a haunting meditation on the nature of evil that lingers long after the final page.
Download our mobile app to enjoy your favorite books on the go. Get access to exclusive features, offline listening, and personalized recommendations.
